Motions

Varsity Finals

  • 1
    This house believes that the wider adoption and scope expansion of restorative justice is within the interest of Indonesian society
  • 2
    THBT states facing existential organized crime threats should permit indefinite extrajudicial detention of suspected cartel and mafia affiliates
  • 3
    This house would universally and uniformly recognize Forum Non Conveniens (FNC) in cross border private disputes
  • Varsity Semifinals

  • 1
    This house regrets the dissolution of Republik Indonesia Serikat
  • 2
    This house prefers a world where the Indian subcontinent became a united federal state over a world where it was partitioned into the sovereign states of India and Pakistan
  • 3
    This house regrets the rejection of Democratic Confederal Republic of Koryo
  • Varsity Quarterfinals

  • 1
    " This house would grant legal amnesty to radical feminist activist that target the dismantling of Manosphere communities and infrastructure (e.g. doxxing of and/or vigilante action directed toward Manosphere figures, physical sabotage of Manosphere events etc) "
  • 2
    This house, as trans feminist movement, would actively push for broader abolishment of gender status (e.g. official gender marker; gender and sex role doctrine; and many other interpretable examples) as the main priority of our activism.
  • 3
    THR the interpretation of subversion in pop feminism
  • High Schools Grand Final

  • 1
    This house believes that developing countries should subject digital labor platforms to the regulatory standards of the sector they operate in (e.g. Grab as a transportation service provider, ShiftMed as healthcare staffing agency etc),
  • 2
    This house believes that Indonesia should recognize a legal right for individuals to personalize their JHT accounts
  • 3
    This house believes that developing countries should position themselves as regulatory havens for experimental regenerative medicine.
  • High Schools Semifinals

  • 1
    This house believes that Western hegemony should prioritize pursuing larger democratization efforts in the West Asia region over containing Iran.
  • 2
    This house opposes the emergence of AES military-led governments in West Africa
  • 3
    This house supports the resurgence of military neutrality in Europe
  • High Schools Quarterfinals

  • 1
    As a feminist, This house would reject and suppress our animus
  • 2
    This house supports the portrayal of women as vengeful supernatural entities in horror media (e.g. Suzanna, Sadako in The Ring, Jennifer White in Jennifer's Body)
  • 3
    This house believes that feminist movements in the Global South should prioritize punitive legal reform (e.g. criminalization of catcalling, marital rape legislation, etc) over social and structural advocacy (e.g. community consent education, bystander intervention programs etc)
  • High Schools Octofinals

  • 1
    This House believes that global ecological frameworks should abandon "Green Growth" policies in favor of enforcing "Post-Growth" policies.
  • 2
    This house prefers the direct distribution of adaptation funding toward the at-risk community rather than through state.
  • 3
    This house believes that indigenous communities should not be criminally punished for vigilante justice (e.g. sabotaging illegal logging equipment, forcibly expelling trespassers, detaining illegal miners, or retaliating against corporations) committed in defense of their ancestral lands.
  • High Schools Round 5

  • 1
    This house supports the widespread use of CND.
  • 2
    This house believes that humanity should embrace the cosmicist view that our extinction and replacement by AI is a natural evolution of the universe.
  • 3
    Assuming feasibility, This house would allow individuals to trade their lifespan for money
  • Varsity Round 4

  • 1
    This house celebrates the rise of state-centralized Islam in the post-caliphate era.
  • 2
    In the interpretation of religious teachings, This house prefers the framework of "God commands it because it's right" over "It's right because God commands it"
  • 3
    This house would mandate the inclusion of contextual footnotes in religious holy books
  • Varsity Round 3

  • 1
    This house believes that the United States federal government should temporarily disregard the debt ceiling during economic crises
  • 2
    This house regrets the commercialization of extra-terrestrial resources (e.g. granting citizens and companies to utilize space resources, deep-space infrastructure)
  • 3
    During retail investor surges, This house would impose a moratorium on leveraged trading
  • High Schools Round 4

  • 1
    This house opposes the imposed expectations of self-sacrifice on religious followers (e.g. obligatory almsgiving, altruistic duty, or glorifying martyrdom)
  • 2
    As organized religions, This house would abandon fear-based messaging (i.e eternal damnation, etc) in religious preachings
  • 3
    This house regrets Indonesia's abandonment of ancestral beliefs (e.g., Animism, Dynamism, Kejawen, Sunda Wiwitan, etc.) in favor of broader adoption of constitutionalized religious beliefs (e.g. Islam, Protestantism, Hinduism, Buddhism, Catholicism, Confucianism)
  • High Schools Round 3

  • 1
    This house regrets the increasing trend of place detachment in modern era (e.g. preference for renting over homeownership, rise of Work From Anywhere)
  • 2
    This house would adopt Genius Loci as a protected attribute in urban planning and development regulations
  • 3
    In states with high rates of skilled emigration, This house would prioritize diaspora re-engagement strategies (e.g. tax incentives, research/business funding etc) over brain drain prevention (e.g. mandatory service bonds for scholarship awardee, higher visa regulations etc.)
  • Varsity Round 2

  • 1
    As a triple-A game studio, This house would choose to distribute funding across a larger number of smaller games as opposed to producing more AAA games.
  • 2
    This house supports the increased usage of generative AI in game development
  • 3
    As Indie game player, This house would exclusively support Steam's alternative platforms over continuing our engagement to Steam
  • Varsity Round 1

  • 1
    This house prefers a world in which family caregiving is evaluated through pragmatic framework rather than moral framework
  • 2
    As parents in fragile democracies, This house would prioritize raising children within a collectivist framework (e.g. group before self mindset, emphasis on interdependency and communal obligation etc) over an individualist framework (e.g. personal self actualization, individual merit etc)
  • 3
    This house believes that parents should respond to children's displaced aggression with gentle redirection (i.e., emotional validation, encourage emotional regulation) rather than firm discipline (i.e., setting clear boundaries, behavioral correction)
  • High Schools Round 2

  • 1
    This house regrets the rise of health-based influencers (e.g. fitness, nutrition, and medical influencers)
  • 2
    This house believes that the commercialization of paganism brings more harm than good
  • 3
    This house predicts a significant increase of younger generations abandoning traditional markers of success (e.g. homeownership, retirement savings, marriage) in exchange for alternative lifestyles (e.g. cohabitation, minimalist living, staying single)
  • High Schools Round 1

  • 1
    This house believes that the primary and secondary education should maintain traditional learning system (e.g. paper centric resources, in-person classes etc) at the expense of rejecting technology-driven learning system (more percentage of online classes, digital tools centric etc)
  • 2
    This house believes that schools should teach national heroes (e.g., founding fathers, independence leaders) as morally flawed individuals rather than as role models
  • 3
    This house supports Australia's U-16 Social Media ban